Skip to main content

Star Ratings

In the interest of transparency, the Karabou Review's star-rating system has been—at least somewhat—illuminated on this page. 

Below are each of the five categories that make up the rating system here on the blog. Each category counts for a total of one star out of the five stars it is possible to earn. It is possible for a book to receive partial points in any category. 

Beneath each category heading are the sorts of questions asked when reviewing a piece. Not all of these questions apply to every piece read, of course, so it isn't possible to offer a full breakdown of how stars are awarded. This should, however, give you at least some idea of what is being evaluated, so you may better understand why a book received the rating it received.


Plot

  • Is the plot sturdy and explainable for the world that it's taking place in?

  • Does the plot progress only because it hinges on absurdities?

    • Deus ex Machina
    • Characters making decisions that are out of character and unexplained
    • Character developing sudden strengths or weaknesses that are unexplained
    • Characters being nothing more than plot devices

  • Are there plot holes? 

  • Is the plot appropriately threaded through the story?


Characters

  • Did the author craft solid psychologies for their characters?

  • Do the characters' personalities / behaviors make sense for their situations and ages?

  • Do the characters feel real (or at least slightly nuanced) or are they just tropes / cardboard / the sort that could be replaced by a lamp without anything changing?

  • How do the characters play off of each other?

  • Do they sound like different people?


Writing

  • Did the writing flow well or was it awkward / stilted / choppy?

  • Did the book need more or less content?

  • How was the pacing?

  • Was the piece compelling / entertaining?

  • Did the dialogue feel organic or contrived?

  • Were there fewer than three typographical errors in the text? 

  • How was the consistency (plot, tone, characters, story details, etc.)?

  • How was the suspension of disbelief? 


World

  • How is the worldbuilding (applies to real-world fiction, too)?

  • Does the author use the setting well?

  • Are the details at least mostly accurate to the time period / physics / science / etc.?


Themes & Audience

  • What audience was the piece aimed at and was it appropriately structured for that audience?

  • Did the piece handle the conversations it started / questions it asked in a meaningful way? 

  • Did it leave the conversation in an appropriate place (An open-ended discussion is fine, but forgetting to finish a conversation is not.)?

  • Were there issues that went unaddressed?


Obviously, we would all prefer to enjoy the books that we're reading, but just because I don't like the book doesn't mean it should be rated poorly. Similarly, just because I love a piece doesn't mean that it is without flaws. 

Hopefully this system is easier to understand and, hopefully, it promotes better organization here on the blog. 

Popular posts from this blog

Book Review: The Darkest Part of the Forest

  I received  The Darkest Part of the Forest  by Holly Black for my birthday in 2019. Since it’s been sitting on my shelf for some time and I’m generally a fan of Holly Black’s work, I decided it was going to be my weekend read a while back. Suffice to say, it didn’t wind up being that and I have very mixed feelings about this book. Rating: 3/5 Buy The Darkest Part of the Forest . Cover Blurb:  "Hazel and her brother, Ben, live in Fairfold, where humans and the Folk exist side by side. Since they were children, Hazel and Ben have been telling each other stories about the boy in the glass coffin: that he is a prince and they are valiant knights. But as Hazel grows up, she puts aside those stories. Hazel knows the horned boy will never wake.  Until one day, he does .... Set in the same world as the bestselling Folk of the Air  series ( The Cruel Prince , The Wicked King , and The Queen of Nothing ), The Darkest Part of the Forest is Holly Black's triumphant ...

Book Review: Night Sky with Exit Wounds

A few days ago, I picked up a copy of  Night Sky with Exit Wounds  by Ocean Vuong. This time, rather than ordering a physical copy, I got an e-book copy because I was disinclined to wait for shipping and I thought I might get around to it faster. Given I started it the minute I put it on my e-reader and finished it within two days, I'd say that decision paid off. It was my third read of 2022 and arguably my favorite, thus far. (This review revision was completed April 15, 2023.) Rating:    4 /5 Buy Night Sky With Exit Wounds Here . Cover Blurb:  " In his haunting and fearless debut, Ocean Vuong walks a tightrope of historic and personal violences, creating an interrogation of the American body as a borderless space of both failure and triumph. At once vulnerable and redemptive, dreamlike and visceral, compassionate and unforgiving, these poems seek a myriad existence without forgetting the prerequisite of self-preservation in a world bent on extinguishing its ot...

Book Review: Big Panda and Tiny Dragon

  By the end of January, I was feeling really overwhelmed, exhausted, and out of sorts. So, I decided that I wanted a quicker, more lightweight read for my next book and I had hoped to find something a little more philosophical. Of course, I didn't have any such books in mind until one of my favorite vloggers recommended  Big Panda and Tiny Dragon by James Norbury. This became my fourth read of 2022*. Rating: 3.5/5 Buy Big Panda And Tiny Dragon . Amazon Blurb: "Big Panda and Tiny Dragon embark on a journey through the seasons of the year together. They get lost, as many of us do. But while lost, they discover many beautiful sights they'd never have found had they gone the right way. Told through a series of beautiful drawings and quiet, sometimes silly, conversations, the panda and the dragon explore the thoughts and emotions, hardships and happiness that connect us all. In nature, they learn how to live in the moment, how to be at peace with uncertainty, and how to find t...